Skip links

Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, & Banana Milkshake

Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, & Banana Milkshake Recipe

Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, & Banana Milkshake Recipe

Introducing Mrs. Miller’s Amish Peanut Butter Milkshake.

When it comes to milkshakes, the classics are well-loved, but if you're ready to explore the world of unique and delightful flavor combinations, Mrs. Miller’s homemade Amish Peanut Butter Milkshake is here to win your heart. This unconventional blend of flavors, featuring the alluring Amish Peanut Butter, is a creamy delight that is surprisingly easy to make at home.

The Allure of Peanut Butter

At the core of this enticing milkshake lies the ever-popular and mouthwatering peanut butter. However, Mrs. Miller's Amish Peanut Butter brings something truly special to the mix - marshmallows! Made with a traditional Amish recipe, this peanut butter boasts a distinct nutty flavor, combined with sweetness in perfect harmony. Its velvety texture and subtle hints of caramelized sweetness set it apart from ordinary nut butters.

The Wholesomeness of Bananas

Completing this trifecta of flavors is the humble banana. Often underestimated, the banana plays a crucial role in this milkshake, enhancing both creaminess and taste. The key lies in selecting the right ripeness of bananas.

Ripe bananas, with their soft texture and intensified sweetness, blend effortlessly into the milkshake, adding a velvety smoothness. On the other hand, unripe bananas offer a subtle tang that can balance the overall sweetness. The choice is yours, depending on your preferred flavor profile.

While the Amish Peanut Butter Milkshake is already a delightful treat on its own, you can unleash your creativity and personalize it further with optional additions. Consider drizzling some luscious chocolate syrup over the milkshake for a decadent touch. Alternatively, sprinkle chopped nuts on top or add a dollop of whipped cream to create a luxurious treat.

  • Prep Time5 min
  • Cook Time5 min
  • Total Time10 min



    Optional Garnishes

    • 1 Marshmallow per glass
    • 1 Slice of Banana in peel per glass
    • 2 TBS Amish Peanut Butter for Bananas and glass swirls
    • Skewers or Decorative Toothpicks



    Garnish glasses with a swirl of Mrs. Miller’s Amish Peanut Butter and place in freezer.


    Place remaining ingredients in a high-powered blender, liquids first, and blend slowly to mix and gradually turn to high until all of the bananas are combined.


    Pour into frozen pre-garnished glasses and place in the refrigerator or freezer.


    Dip 1 Marshmallow in Mrs. Miller’s Amish Peanut Butter, skewer with a slice of Banana, and set on the side of the glass for a festive look.


    Serve cold and enjoy!

    Share with friends